THE POWER OF RECALL: AN ELECTORAL JOKER NIGERIAN VOTERS HAVE NOT YET USED – By Amira Sanni

Democracy Does Not End at the Ballot Box: It is Time to Hold Elected Representatives Accountable

Nigeria’s democracy is at a critical point where citizens must begin to rethink their understanding of political participation and the powers they possess under the Constitution.

Every election season, millions of Nigerians troop out to vote, exercise their franchise and entrust their future to individuals seeking elective office. They campaign, mobilise, persuade, endure political promises and eventually cast their votes in the hope of better representation and improved governance. Unfortunately, what often follows is a familiar and disappointing experience. Some elected representatives become inaccessible immediately after securing electoral victory. Constituents who were courted with promises suddenly struggle to see or hear from those they elected. Some representatives appear to forget the people who gave them their mandate, while others demonstrate little evidence of meaningful legislative contributions, constituency engagement or commitment to the welfare of their communities.

The question, therefore, is: Must Nigerians wait until another election before holding non-performing elected representatives accountable?

The answer is NO!

There is a constitutional democratic instrument available to Nigerian voters which, regrettably, remains largely underutilised and insufficiently understood: THE POWER OF RECALL.

What Is the Power of Recall?

Recall is a constitutional provision that empowers voters to withdraw the mandate given to an elected representative before the expiration of their tenure when they have lost confidence in that representative.

Under Sections 69 and 110 of the 1999 Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, as amended, voters have the right to initiate the recall of members of the National Assembly and State Houses of Assembly respectively.

The Electoral Act 2022 also provides for the recall of councillors in the Area Councils of the Federal Capital Territory.

This means that an elected legislator does not possess an unconditional licence to occupy public office for four years, regardless of performance, conduct or commitment to the electorate. The mandate belongs to the people, and the Constitution provides a process through which they can withdraw it.

This is an important democratic safeguard that Nigerians must begin to appreciate and exercise responsibly.

How Does Recall Work?

The constitutional procedure is straightforward in principle, although it requires substantial organisation and compliance with INEC’s regulations.

Loss of confidence: Constituents who have lost confidence in their elected representative may initiate a recall process.

Petition: A petition alleging loss of confidence must be submitted to the Chairman of the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC). It must be signed by more than one-half of the registered voters in the constituency.

Verification: INEC verifies the signatures to establish that the constitutional threshold has been met.

Referendum: Once the petition satisfies the requirements, INEC conducts a referendum within 90 days of receiving the petition.

Decision: The recall succeeds when the referendum satisfies the constitutional requirement of approval by a simple majority of the votes of registered voters in the constituency.

Upon a successful recall, the representative loses the seat, and the appropriate electoral process is undertaken to fill the vacancy.

This is not an imaginary democratic instrument or a political theory. It is a constitutional right that Nigerian citizens can invoke.

Why Have Nigerians Not Taken Advantage of This Power?

One wonders why, despite widespread dissatisfaction with political representation across different levels of government, the recall mechanism has not become a more familiar instrument of democratic accountability.

Several factors may explain this.

First is inadequate civic education. Many Nigerians are familiar with the process of electing representatives but know very little about the constitutional provisions that empower them to demand accountability after elections.

Second is political resignation. There appears to be an unfortunate belief that once an individual has been elected, constituents must simply endure whatever follows until the next election in four years.

Third is the politics of patronage. Some voters have come to accept occasional financial inducements, gifts and personal favours as substitutes for effective representation and sustainable development.

Fourth is the difficulty of collective action. Recall requires more than expressions of anger on social media or complaints in community meetings. It requires organised citizens, credible evidence of loss of confidence, extensive mobilisation and compliance with established electoral procedures.

These challenges, however, should not discourage Nigerians from exploring a constitutional option that strengthens their democratic voice.

What Should Constituents Demand from Their Representatives?

Before considering recall, voters must also understand what meaningful representation entails.

An elected legislator should be assessed against clear expectations, including:

1. Regular engagement with constituents and accessibility to the people.
2. Active participation in legislative debates and the discharge of legislative responsibilities.
3. Effective representation of constituency interests in policy discussions and national development priorities.
4. Constructive contributions to legislation, oversight and accountability.
5. Transparency regarding constituency projects and public resources.
6. Responsiveness to the economic, social and developmental challenges confronting the constituency.

Representation should be measured by service, responsibility, integrity and tangible contributions, not merely political visibility, party loyalty or the distribution of occasional handouts.

Of course, not every unfulfilled campaign promise automatically justifies recall. Representatives operate within institutional, budgetary and political constraints. Recall must therefore be based on a genuine, collectively established loss of confidence, not personal disagreements, political vendettas or temporary partisan interests.

Recall Is Not a Weapon; It Is an Instrument of Democratic Accountability

It is important to emphasise that recall should not become another instrument for political intimidation, harassment or destabilisation. It must be exercised within the law, guided by facts, fairness and the collective will of the electorate.

The objective is not to punish politicians for disagreeing with particular individuals or groups. It is to remind public office holders that electoral victory comes with continuing obligations to the people.

Indeed, the possibility of recall could encourage elected representatives to maintain regular contact with their constituencies, demonstrate greater commitment to their legislative responsibilities and take their mandates more seriously.

A representative who knows that constituents can constitutionally initiate the withdrawal of their mandate has an additional incentive to remain accountable. Knowing that someone has been successfully recalled in the past should instill greater humility and sense of duty.

This is how democratic institutions become stronger: not simply through elections, but through continuous citizen participation and institutional checks on the exercise of public authority.

A Call to Nigerian Voters: Move Beyond Complaints to Constitutional Action

As Nigeria approaches another cycle of political mobilisation and electoral competition, citizens must begin to ask more fundamental questions about the quality of representation they receive.

We cannot continue to complain about poor leadership while ignoring the democratic instruments available to us. We cannot demand accountability from the executive alone while overlooking the responsibilities of our elected legislators. We cannot insist that politicians must keep their promises if we are unwilling to use lawful mechanisms to question their performance.

The power of recall offers an opportunity to change this narrative.

Citizens should organise town hall meetings, demand constituency reports, monitor legislative performance, request information on public projects and engage their representatives constructively.

Where there is a genuine and widespread loss of confidence, they should familiarise themselves with INEC’s recall guidelines and consider exercising their constitutional rights.

INEC, civil society organisations, the media, community leaders and educational institutions also have an important responsibility to promote public awareness of this provision.

It is particularly important that civic education on recall becomes part of Nigeria’s broader democratic education, so that citizens understand not only how to elect leaders but also how to hold them accountable.

One important clarification: the constitutional recall provisions discussed here apply to legislators. They do not provide a recall procedure for the President, state governors or local government chairmen, who are subject to other constitutional and legal accountability mechanisms.

The Ballot Box Must Not Be the Last Word

Ultimately, democracy is not a four-year conversation between politicians and the electorate. It is a continuous social contract built on trust, responsibility, representation and accountability.

The right to vote gives citizens the power to choose their leaders. The right to recall gives them a constitutional means of withdrawing that mandate from certain elected representatives when the required conditions are met.

Nigerians must therefore move from being passive spectators in their democracy to becoming active participants in its preservation.

Let every elected representative understand that the people are watching. Let every constituency know that its mandate carries responsibilities. Let every voter understand that democracy provides more than the opportunity to elect leaders; it also provides lawful avenues to demand accountability.

Nigerians, the next time your elected representative fails to justify the mandate entrusted to them, remember that you have another constitutional option. You do not necessarily have to wait for the next election season.

USE YOUR VOTE WISELY. MONITOR YOUR REPRESENTATIVES. DEMAND ACCOUNTABILITY. AND WHEN NECESSARY, EXERCISE YOUR CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT OF RECALL.

The power belongs to the people. It is time they became conscious of it and used it responsibly.

Democracy must not be a licence for politicians to govern without accountability. It must remain an instrument through which the people exercise sovereignty.

**Amira Sanni is a Civil Society advocate and writes from Abuja.

Loading